Litchfield County Courthouse/Abner Hotel

The project to convert the historic Litchfield County Courthouse into a boutique hotel with a restaurant, bar, and amenities was an ambitious effort by the Greater Litchfield Preservation Trust in partnership with Lexington Partners. This adaptive reuse initiative sought to revitalize a building that has been central to the community's history and economy for over 250 years. The Courthouse, a defining landmark in the heart of Litchfield, Connecticut, was once a crucial site for local judicial functions and long served as a focal point of the town’s identity. However, following the state’s decision to move judicial functions to Torrington in 2017, the building was left vacant, posing both a preservation challenge and an opportunity for new community-centered development.

The Courthouse has been a vital part of Litchfield’s history since 1795 when it became the county seat. Constructed in 1888, the building, with its iconic granite exterior and clock tower, is a striking example of 19th-century public architecture. It was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1978 and has been a cornerstone of the Litchfield Historic District since 1959. Over the years, the building hosted not only judicial functions but also a range of civic activities, contributing to the town’s social and economic fabric. However, after the state moved its judicial services to a new courthouse in Torrington, the Litchfield Courthouse became largely neglected, which led to significant deterioration and a complex set of challenges for its preservation.

The Greater Litchfield Preservation Trust, which purchased the building in 2017, has faced a number of obstacles in preserving and reusing the Courthouse. One major challenge was the need to balance preservation with modern functionality. Due to the building’s historic significance, it could not be altered drastically without compromising its integrity which necessitated careful planning and thoughtful design. The Trust, in collaboration with Lexington Partners, secured a façade easement on the 1888 historic portion of the building as well as an amendment for parking regulations and a variance of a boundary line for the tower which was required for ADA access. Litchfield Historic District Commission approvals were secured, as well as approvals from the Connecticut State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) and the Department of the Interior. This has allowed for the preservation of the Courthouse’s iconic 1888 granite façade and clock tower while ensuring that the interior renovations, featuring a boutique hotel with 19 rooms, a restaurant, bar, and other amenities, were also sensitive to its historical features.

Another significant challenge was the high cost of restoration and adaptive reuse. The Trust faced difficulty securing funding, particularly after the Town of Litchfield rejected a proposal to use the building for municipal offices due to an estimated $8 million cost of adaptation. However, the Trust’s team, recognizing the potential for the Courthouse to once again serve as a community asset, pursued tax credits to offset a large portion of the renovation costs. A feasibility study, commissioned by the Trust, highlighted that a boutique hotel would be the most viable option for the building’s reuse, noting that not only would this preserve the structure’s historic character, but also inject much-needed economic activity into the local community, particularly by drawing tourists to town. The use of historic tax credits was essential for making this project financially feasible, as they provided approximately $2 million in support, helping to bridge the gap between the building’s restoration costs and the project’s financial needs.

The impact of this project on the community is substantial. It preserved a key piece of Litchfield’s history and will also provide a new economic driver for the town. Tourism has long been a vital part of Litchfield’s economy, and the hotel will help reinforce its position as one of Connecticut’s top tourist destinations. The project also offers employment opportunities, not only during the construction phase but also with the operation of the hotel, further benefiting the local economy. By preserving and reusing a historic structure, the project aligns with broader goals of sustainability and cultural heritage conservation, ensuring that future generations can continue to enjoy the Courthouse’s architectural beauty and historical significance.

The adaptive reuse of the Litchfield County Courthouse into a boutique hotel is an outstanding achievement that successfully balances historical preservation with modern development, addressing the challenges of maintaining a historic building while finding a practical and economically beneficial use for it. The project’s careful planning, innovative strategies, and focus on community impact make it a model for how historic structures can be repurposed to benefit both the community and the broader economy. By revitalizing this iconic building, the Trust and its partners are ensuring that the Courthouse remains an enduring symbol of Litchfield’s heritage, while contributing to its vibrant future.

‍